Annex X Comparison of phased approach with Single Scheme

Phase one (original scheme)		Single scheme for contiguous footstreets scheme		Phase 2 Phase Further phase to protect the rest of the contiguous footstreets, after phase one installation
Location	Measures	Location	Measures	Location	Measures
Parliament Street	Sliding bollard system controlled access/egress 23 static bollards	Parliament Street	Sliding bollard system controlled access/egress 23 static bollards
Spurriergate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 8 static bollards	Spurriergate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 8 static bollards
Coney Street	Sliding bollard system controlled egress 2 static bollards	Lendal	Sliding bollard system controlled egress 5 static bollards	Lendal	Sliding bollard system controlled egress 5 static bollards
Davygate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 4 static bollards	Blake Street	Sliding bollard system controlled access 2 static bollards	Blake Street	Sliding bollard system controlled access 2 static bollards
St Sampson’s Square	Sliding bollard system controlled access/egress Sliding bollard system controlled egress 14 static bollards	Goodramgate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 2 static bollards	Goodramgate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 2 static bollards
		Colliergate	Sliding bollard system controlled egress 5 static bollards	Colliergate	Sliding bollard system controlled egress 5 static bollards
		High Petergate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 3 static bollards	High Petergate	Sliding bollard system controlled access 3 static bollards
		The Shambles	Sliding bollard system controlled access or similar 2 static bollards	The Shambles	Sliding bollard system controlled access or similar 2 static bollards
Jubbergate	5 static bollards 2 lift out bollards	St Andrewgate	Replace 5 bollards	St Andrewgate	Replace 5 bollards
		Minster Gates	Replace 4 bollards	Minster Gates	Replace 4 bollards
Finkle Street	1 static bollard
Coppergate to Ousegate path	1 static bollard	Coppergate to Ousegate path	1 static bollard
Total	2 Sliding systems - large 4 Sliding systems - medium 2 lift out bollards 58 static bollards		2 Sliding systems - large 5 Sliding systems - medium 1 Sliding systems – small, or similar 60 static bollards		Additional: 5 Sliding systems - medium 1 Sliding systems – small, or similar 28 static bollards Total: 2 Sliding systems - large 9 Sliding systems – medium 1 sliding system - small 86 static bollards
Estimated cost	Phase 1 £1.7M		£1.7M Total £1.7M		Additional £1.6M on top of phase 1 Total £3.3M